Then one day I got a brilliant idea. I went to Hobby Lobby (love that store) and bought a certificate frame (it was 50% off so I paid $6) and printed a new chart. I put the chart inside the frame and hung it on the wall. The plexiglass comes clean a lot better than the contact paper. We also had to get some new fine point markers but it looks and works a lot better.
Now I need to figure out what I'm doing for the family home evening chart (I'm still using the lovely post-its) and that little wall will look nice. I have two ideas I'm going back and forth on. I want something simple and maybe something with our pictures instead of names. I'm sure I'll decide soon and let you know.